Skip to main content
Scottish football

St Mirren v Hibernian preview: one win in five meets none in five

St Mirren sit sixth and Hibernian bottom, yet Hibernian have the better goal difference. Which matters more at the SMISA Stadium on Wednesday?

· · 3 min read

Add as a preferred source on Google
Lucky Tiger News title card: St Mirren v Hibernian preview: one win in five meets none in five

St Mirren are sixth in the Scottish Premiership and Hibernian are bottom, but Hibernian have the better goal difference. That tension shapes Wednesday's meeting at the SMISA Stadium (19:45 kick-off). The hosts have the points; the visitors have a goal record less damaged than their position suggests.

St Mirren have 13 points from ten matches. Hibernian have seven from nine. St Mirren have conceded 18 league goals, more than any side bar Kilmarnock.

TeamPosPPtsGFGAGDHome W-D-LAway W-D-L
St Mirren610131118-72-1-22-0-3
Hibernian1297914-50-1-42-0-2

Does the Dundee win change the picture?

Before Saturday's 2-1 home win over Dundee, St Mirren had lost four league matches in a row and failed to score in three of them. The run included a 5-0 defeat at Hearts and a 3-0 home loss to Dundee United, which explains most of that goal difference.

The context is important, though. Three of those four defeats came against sides now in the top four: Rangers (1-0 away), Dundee United and Hearts. The fourth was a 3-1 loss at Aberdeen. And the win came against Dundee, the side directly above them in fifth. My reading is that St Mirren's record is weaker against the division's stronger teams than against the rest, and Hibernian, on current form, are not one of the stronger teams.

The caution is at home. A 2-1-2 record at their own ground is respectable rather than commanding, and one of those home defeats was the 3-0 against Dundee United.

Can Hibernian find goals?

This is the bigger question for the visitors. Hibernian have scored nine league goals in nine matches, and in their last five they scored once in three and not at all in two. They have not scored more than once in any of those games.

The defeats have been narrow: 2-1 at St Johnstone, 1-0 at home to Kilmarnock, 1-0 at Dundee United and 2-1 at home to Falkirk, with a 1-1 home draw against Aberdeen in between. That is consistent with a side that is competitive but not creating enough, rather than one being overrun.

Their away record of two wins and two defeats is the strongest part of their case. Both wins came earlier in the season, though: their two away matches in the last five were both lost. Most of the damage has been done at home, where they have yet to win a league match.

The opposition in that run also counts against them. Apart from Dundee United, the sides they lost to sit seventh, eighth and eleventh. These were not the toughest fixtures available.

Does the history help?

Only a little. Hibernian won four of the last eight league meetings, St Mirren two, with two draws, and Hibernian won three of the five played at St Mirren. But the most recent of those was in February 2023, and the teams have not met this season. Squads change over that kind of gap, so I give it little weight.

Verdict

I lean towards St Mirren, narrowly. They have the better recent result, the home setting and an opponent that has struggled to score. Draws have been rare for both sides this season, with one each, which points towards a decisive result rather than a stalemate.

The main risk is St Mirren's defence. A team with the second-worst goals against record in the division can give Hibernian chances they have not been creating elsewhere, and Hibernian's tight defeats suggest a single goal could swing it. If the visitors reproduce their earlier away form, a narrow away win is entirely plausible.

What would change my view: line-ups. I would revisit this assessment once both teams are confirmed, particularly if either side is without a regular attacker.

Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables).

How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Harvey Watkins's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.

More Scottish football