Skip to main content
Scottish football

Hibernian v Dundee United preview: Hibs still seek a home win

Hibernian have won three league games this season, all away from home. Dundee United arrive at Easter Road unbeaten in five, but three straight draws raise questions of their own.

· · 3 min read

Add as a preferred source on Google
Lucky Tiger News title card: Hibernian v Dundee United preview: Hibs still seek a home win

Dundee United arrive at Easter Road on Saturday 21 November (15:00) as the more consistent side, and the evidence gives them a slight edge. The case is closer than the table suggests, though, because Hibernian's season looks very different depending on where they play.

Why can't Hibernian win at home?

Hibernian sit tenth in the Scottish Premiership with 11 points from 12 matches. All three of their league wins have come on the road. Away from Easter Road they have won three, drawn one and lost two. At home they have won none of six, with one draw and five defeats.

That home record is the strongest single point against the hosts, but it needs context. Their two most recent home matches were 2-1 defeats by Falkirk and Celtic, who sit third and first. Losing narrowly to the top two in form is a different problem from being outplayed by sides around them.

Hibernian's wider numbers are also kinder than their position. They have conceded 17 league goals, the same as Dundee United, and only Rangers, Celtic, Falkirk and Dundee have conceded fewer. Their goal difference of -2 is better than five other teams, three of which are above them in the table: St Johnstone, St Mirren and Motherwell.

Their most recent result was their best: a 4-0 win at Aberdeen on 7 November. I'd treat that with some caution. Aberdeen are 11th and have lost four of their last five league matches, so it tells us Hibernian can punish a struggling side, not that the home problem is solved.

Are Dundee United's draws a strength or a ceiling?

Dundee United are sixth on 17 points, level with Dundee in fifth and St Johnstone in seventh. They are unbeaten in five league matches, winning two and drawing three, including the last three in a row.

Those draws vary in quality. A 2-2 at Celtic on 28 October is the best result either side has produced in this run. A 1-1 at home to Motherwell, who are ninth, on 7 November is less convincing. Five draws from 12 matches is the joint-highest total in the division, alongside St Johnstone, and their goals tally of 17 scored and 17 conceded points the same way: United are hard to beat, but they rarely pull clear.

Their away record of two wins, two draws and two defeats offers no strong pattern either way. It suggests a side comfortable travelling rather than one that dominates on the road.

How much does the head-to-head tell us?

United won the first meeting this season 1-0 at home on 10 October. That was the first of three straight league defeats for Hibernian, and it is the most relevant meeting simply because it is the most recent.

In the eight league meetings before that, between January 2021 and October 2024, United won four, Hibernian won two and two were drawn. Three of those were at Easter Road: two draws and a 3-0 United win in October 2021. Hibernian have not won any of those home meetings, but I'd give that limited weight. The most recent of the eight was in October 2024, and squads change considerably over that span.

Verdict

The evidence narrowly favours Dundee United. They are in better form, higher in the table, won the meeting six weeks ago and have avoided defeat at Celtic. A draw would also sit comfortably with both sides' patterns, given United's run and Hibernian's tight home defeats.

The main risk to that view is Hibernian's away form. They have shown they can win matches, and their last two home defeats were by a single goal against the top-three sides. If the team that won 4-0 at Aberdeen carries that into Saturday, a winless home run of six can end against an opponent that has drawn its last three.

I'd revisit the assessment once both line-ups are confirmed, because availability could shift a match this evenly balanced.

Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables).

How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Harvey Watkins's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.

More Scottish football