Premiership matchday 10: bottom three lose, Dundee United go fourth
Hibernian, Kilmarnock and Motherwell all lost, Dundee United climbed to fourth and Celtic stayed perfect on the road. Here's what Matchday 10 changed.
Add as a preferred source on Google
The most telling line from Matchday 10 isn't at the top of the Scottish Premiership. It's at the bottom, where Hibernian, Kilmarnock and Motherwell all lost and not one of the bottom three added a point.
That's the main story of the weekend. Around it: Dundee United's climb into fourth, a top two that didn't blink and a middle of the table that's getting crowded.
| Date | Result |
|---|---|
| 24 October | Dundee United 3-2 Aberdeen |
| 24 October | Falkirk 3-0 Kilmarnock |
| 24 October | Rangers 4-0 St Johnstone |
| 24 October | St Mirren 2-1 Dundee |
| 25 October | Hibernian 1-2 Celtic |
| 25 October | Motherwell 0-2 Hearts |
A bottom three going nowhere
Hibernian stay bottom on 7 points. Motherwell and Kilmarnock sit on 8. Aberdeen, in ninth, have 11. Nobody below Aberdeen moved, and that's the problem for all three.
Motherwell have now lost their last five league matches. Hibernian have one draw from their last five, and the Celtic defeat isn't what worries me. Their home record is: six league games at home, no wins, one draw and five defeats. Both their wins this season came away.
Kilmarnock are the side I'd watch most closely, though. They've conceded 23 goals, the most in the division, and their goal difference of -13 is the worst by some distance. The fair objection is that they've won twice in their last five, which is more recent form than Motherwell or Hibs can show. That's real. But a side shipping goals at that level is relying on the results running kinder than the performances. My view: Kilmarnock are the most exposed of the three on the evidence of the goals column, even if Hibs are the ones holding up the table.
Dundee United into fourth, with a caveat
Dundee United beat Aberdeen 3-2 and moved from fifth to fourth on 15 points. They swapped places with Dundee, who lost 2-1 at St Mirren and stay on 14. United are unbeaten in five: two draws and three wins.
Credit where it's due. But their season-long numbers are dead level: 14 scored, 14 conceded, a goal difference of zero. Five teams sit between 11 and 14 points directly below them. Fourth place on those figures looks held rather than owned. If United start keeping the goals-against column under control, I'll change that view. Until then, I'd treat fourth as the reward for a good run, not proof of a new level.
The top two don't flinch
Celtic won 2-1 at Hibernian and stay top on 27 points: nine wins from ten, 26 scored, 6 conceded. Away from home they've played five and won five. Their only league defeat came at home.
Rangers beat St Johnstone 4-0 and stay second on 23. They're unbeaten away (three wins, two draws), and like Celtic their one defeat came at home. Celtic's goal difference of 20 against Rangers' 10 is the clearest gap between them, and it's why Celtic remain the side to catch.
Hearts held third on 19 by winning 2-0 at Motherwell. At home they're perfect, four from four. Away they've lost three of six, which is why third looks a more natural home for them than anything higher.
Sixth to ninth is a scramble
St Mirren ended a four-match losing run and climbed from eighth to sixth on 13 points. Falkirk's 3-0 win over Kilmarnock lifted them from ninth to seventh on 12; it was only their second home win in five. St Johnstone dropped from sixth to eighth, also on 12, and Aberdeen slid from seventh to ninth on 11.
Of that group, St Mirren's position is the one I trust least. Their goal difference of -7 is the weakest of the sides between fifth and ninth, so sixth is being propped up by results rather than the balance of goals.
What to watch next
Three questions will shape the next round: whether Motherwell can stop a losing run that has reached five, whether Hibernian can finally win a home league match, and whether Dundee United's unbeaten run survives long enough to make fourth look permanent. Any one of those answers would change the picture more than another win for the top two.
Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables).
How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Barrie Moran's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.


