Skip to main content
Scottish football

St Johnstone v Motherwell: same goal record, very different form

Both sides have scored 11 and conceded 16 in the league. What separates them is recent form, and how much of Motherwell's losing run is down to the fixture list.

· · 3 min read

Add as a preferred source on Google
Lucky Tiger News title card: St Johnstone v Motherwell: same goal record, very different form

Motherwell travel to McDiarmid Park on Wednesday (19:45 kick-off) having lost their last five Scottish Premiership matches. St Johnstone have won only one of their last five, but they have lost just once at home in the league all season. On the surface, that points one way. Underneath, these two sides are closer than the table suggests.

Their league goal records are identical: 11 scored, 16 conceded and a goal difference of minus five each. St Johnstone are eighth with 12 points from ten matches. Motherwell are tenth with eight points from nine, so they also have a game in hand on the hosts.

TeamPositionPlayedPointsHome W-D-LAway W-D-LLast five (oldest first)
St Johnstone8th10122-2-11-1-3L D W D L
Motherwell10th981-1-21-1-3L L L L L

How much of Motherwell's run is the fixture list?

Some of it, clearly. Three of the five defeats came against sides now in the top five: 1-0 away to Rangers, 2-1 away to Dundee and 2-0 at home to Celtic. A one-goal defeat to Rangers and a loss to the league leaders aren't, on their own, evidence of a side in decline.

The other two results are harder to explain away. Aberdeen, currently ninth, won 4-0 at Motherwell on 15 September, and Kilmarnock, 11th, won 3-2 on 17 October. Across the five defeats, Motherwell conceded at least twice in four and scored in only two. My concern is less the quality of the opposition than what the defence has allowed against it.

Can St Johnstone turn home form into wins?

McDiarmid Park has been a reasonably solid base. St Johnstone's only home league defeat this season was the 2-0 loss to Celtic on 9 September. Since then they have drawn 1-1 at home with both Falkirk and Dundee United, which means neither of their two home wins came in their last five matches.

Strip out the two Old Firm fixtures from that run and the picture improves: unbeaten in three, with a 1-0 win at Aberdeen and those two draws, conceding no more than once in any of them. The limitation is at the other end. In their last five league matches they never scored more than once and failed to score twice, against Celtic and in Saturday's 4-0 defeat at Rangers. A side that keeps games tight but scores this sparingly can find a draw just as easily as a win.

Do past meetings help?

Only a little. The sides haven't met yet this season. Their last eight league meetings ran from February 2021 to May 2023: St Johnstone won four, Motherwell two, and two were drawn. At McDiarmid Park in that sequence it was one win each and two draws, with Motherwell winning the most recent of those, 2-0, in May 2023. Squads and circumstances change a lot over three seasons, so I'd give these results little weight.

Verdict

The evidence slightly favours St Johnstone. They have only one home defeat, they have handled the sides outside the top two well over their last five, and Motherwell have conceded at least twice in four of their five straight losses.

It is a narrow lean, not a strong one. The matching goal records suggest little separates these teams over the season, and three of Motherwell's defeats came against the top five. The main risk to the view is St Johnstone's scoring: if they can't turn a tight game into a winning one, a draw is very much in range. Confirmed team news, once available, is the main thing that could change this assessment in either direction.

Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables).

How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Harvey Watkins's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.

More Scottish football