Skip to main content
Scottish football

St Johnstone 2-1 Dundee: first win in five, but still seventh

St Johnstone ended a four-match wait for a league win at McDiarmid Park, yet three clubs on 17 points left them exactly where they started.

· · 2 min read

Add as a preferred source on Google
Lucky Tiger News title card: St Johnstone 2-1 Dundee: first win in five, but still seventh

St Johnstone's 2-1 win over Dundee at McDiarmid Park on Saturday did more for their form than for their league position. It was their first league win in five matches, and it still left them seventh, exactly where they would have been had the game never been played.

That's the Premiership's middle for you. St Johnstone, Dundee and Dundee United all sit on 17 points, and goal difference does the sorting: Dundee fifth on plus three, United sixth on zero, St Johnstone seventh on minus four. Falkirk are a point above them in fourth. St Johnstone have also played a game more than all three.

Still, the run needed a win. Before Saturday they had drawn three of four, with a 4-0 defeat at Rangers in the middle. Two of those draws finished 2-2, against Motherwell and Kilmarnock, so the goals were turning up even when the wins weren't. Home has been the steadier ground: three wins, three draws and one defeat at McDiarmid Park this season. Add the 1-1 draw at Dundee on 2 September and they are unbeaten against Dundee this term.

For Dundee, this was the away problem again. Six league trips have brought two wins and four defeats, while they have lost only once in six at home. Their last five read win, draw, defeat, win, defeat, and they haven't put two of the same result together in that spell. I'd call that inconsistency rather than decline: they remain fifth, with the best goal difference of the three clubs on 17.

Both go again on Saturday 21 November. St Johnstone travel to Falkirk, who have won their last four, and then to Dundee United. That pair of away games is the real test, because St Johnstone have one win from six on the road. Dundee host Hearts at 17:45, then play their game in hand at bottom-placed Hibernian on Tuesday 24 November. Hibs are still looking for a home league win this season.

My view: this win steadies St Johnstone without proving the run has turned. Take something from those two away trips and I'll revise that.

Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables).

How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Barrie Moran's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.

What's next

St Johnstone

  • Sat 21 Nov, 15:00 Falkirk v St Johnstone Read the preview Falkirk Stadium
  • Sat 28 Nov, 15:00 Dundee United v St Johnstone Preview to come Tannadice Park

Dundee

  • Sat 21 Nov, 17:45 Dundee v Hearts Read the preview Dens Park (Kilmac Stadium)
  • Tue 24 Nov, 19:45 Hibernian v Dundee Preview to come Easter Road

More Scottish football