Skip to main content
Scottish football

Ross County and Hamilton stay level as Montrose climb to third

Ross County and Hamilton both won to stay level on 31 points at the top of League One. Montrose moved into third and Queen of the South climbed out of the bottom three.

· · 3 min read

Add as a preferred source on Google
Lucky Tiger News title card: Ross County and Hamilton stay level as Montrose climb to third

Scottish League One has a two-team title race, and Matchday 12 gave nobody a reason to doubt it. Ross County and Hamilton Academical both won, both remain unbeaten and both sit on 31 points. The more interesting movement came further down, among sides whose league positions flatter them a little.

  • Alloa Athletic 0-1 Queen of the South
  • Hamilton Academical 2-1 East Fife
  • Montrose 3-0 Peterhead
  • Ross County 4-0 Airdrieonians

Cove Rangers v East Kilbride, also scheduled for 24 October, has still to be played.

The top two: identical records, different routes

Ross County beat Airdrieonians 4-0 and stay top on goal difference. Hamilton beat East Fife 2-1 and stay second. Ignore the goal difference and you can't separate them: played 11, won 10, drawn 1, lost 0, five straight wins each.

How they get there is another matter. Ross County have scored 42 and conceded 6, a goal difference of 36 that suggests most opponents are turning up to fulfil the fixture. Hamilton have scored a lot fewer, 25, but conceded only 4, the meanest defence in the division, and they've won all six league matches at home.

My view is that Ross County are the stronger side on this evidence. Scoring at that rate gives them a cushion on an off day that Hamilton's tighter wins don't. The strongest objection is Hamilton's defence: four conceded across 11 matches looks like a pattern rather than a fluke. If Hamilton keep grinding out narrow wins while Ross County's goals dry up, I'd reassess. The meetings between the two will settle more than any number of four-goal afternoons against the rest.

Montrose go third, which says plenty about the pack

Montrose beat Peterhead 3-0 and moved from fourth to third on 19 points. Their last five reads win, defeat, defeat, draw, win, and they've won four of six at home. Fair play to them.

But they are third with a goal difference of minus three, and that tells you how thin the chasing pack is. East Kilbride, fourth on 18, have a goal difference of plus five, are unbeaten in their last five and have their game at Cove Rangers from this round still to come. If I were Montrose, I wouldn't be getting comfortable in third.

Queen of the South: sixth, with the worst defence

The 1-0 win at Alloa lifted Queen of the South from eighth to sixth, and three wins in their last five is genuine progress. Yet they've conceded 34 league goals, the most in the division by a distance, and their goal difference of minus 21 is the worst in the league. Sixth with that defensive record says less about a Queens revival than about how forgiving this part of the table is.

They're level on 13 points with Airdrieonians, who have now lost two in a row and shipped four at Ross County. Airdrie have scored 10 in 12, which won't keep them in fifth for long if that continues.

Alloa slide, East Fife and Cove stuck

Alloa dropped from sixth to seventh. That's four defeats in their last five and one home win from six attempts all season. Peterhead fell to eighth, also with four losses in five, and have scored just 9 league goals.

East Fife became one of the few sides to score against Hamilton this season and still went home with nothing. They have one win in 12, and while six draws suggest they're awkward to beat, four defeats in their last five suggest that's wearing off. Cove Rangers are bottom on six points and have lost all six away matches. Their outstanding home game with East Kilbride is a chance to add to that total, and on current form a stiff one.

What to watch

Cove Rangers v East Kilbride has a direct bearing on who holds third, and on whether Cove can start climbing. At the top, Ross County and Hamilton have each played 11 to Montrose's 12, and neither has given the other an inch. My verdict stands: Ross County on the strength of their scoring, with Hamilton's defence the one thing that could make me wrong.

Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables).

How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Barrie Moran's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.

More Scottish football