Motherwell v St Mirren preview: same goal record, different returns
Both sides have scored 11 and conceded 18 in the league, yet St Mirren are sixth and Motherwell 10th after five straight defeats. They meet at Fir Park on Saturday at 15:00.
Add as a preferred source on Google
Motherwell and St Mirren have each scored 11 league goals this season and conceded 18. The difference is what they have done with them. St Mirren have four wins and 13 points, enough for sixth in the Scottish Premiership. Motherwell have two wins and eight points, and sit 10th, ahead of Kilmarnock only on goal difference.
They meet at Fir Park on Saturday 31 October at 15:00. Three questions shape how I read it.
| League record | Motherwell | St Mirren |
|---|---|---|
| Position | 10th | 6th |
| Points | 8 | 13 |
| Won, drawn, lost | 2, 2, 6 | 4, 1, 5 |
| Goals for and against | 11, 18 | 11, 18 |
| Venue record for this match | Home: 1, 1, 3 | Away: 2, 0, 3 |
| Last five (oldest first) | L L L L L | L L L L W |
Who have the defeats come against?
Both sides have had a poor run. Motherwell have lost their last five league matches. St Mirren lost four in a row before beating Dundee 2-1 at home on 24 October. Each has scored three goals in its last five.
The opposition matters, though. St Mirren's four defeats came against Rangers, Dundee United, Hearts and Aberdeen, and three of those sit in the top four. Motherwell's run includes losses to Aberdeen, ninth, and Kilmarnock, 11th, as well as Celtic, Hearts and Dundee. A 3-2 defeat at Kilmarnock is harder to explain away than a heavy loss at Hearts.
The shared opponents give a mixed picture. St Mirren beat Dundee, who beat Motherwell 2-1 in September. But Motherwell's 2-0 home defeat by Hearts looks more respectable than St Mirren's 5-0 loss away to the same side, and Aberdeen beat both comfortably. My reading is that St Mirren's slump owes more to the fixture list than Motherwell's does, but five games is a small sample and the case is not overwhelming.
Can Motherwell score at Fir Park?
Motherwell's home record is one win, one draw and three defeats. All three of those defeats have come in the current run: 4-0 against Aberdeen, 2-0 against Celtic and 2-0 against Hearts, without a goal in any of them. That is the hosts' central problem. Their defensive record barely matters if they can't find a way through at the other end.
There is a fair counterpoint. Celtic and Hearts are first and third, and Motherwell did score away from home in the same spell, twice at Kilmarnock and once at Dundee. St Mirren, on recent evidence, are a less demanding visitor than either of those home opponents.
Do St Mirren travel well enough?
St Mirren's away record is two wins and three defeats, with no draws. The three defeats are their last three trips: 1-0 at Rangers, 5-0 at Hearts and 3-1 at Aberdeen. Both away wins came earlier in the season. The home win over Dundee ended the losing run, but it tells us little about how they cope on the road.
What the meetings add
The sides drew 3-3 when St Mirren hosted on 30 August, a useful reminder that this fixture need not follow either team's recent scoring pattern. The older head-to-head favours Motherwell, who won four of the last eight league meetings before this season, lost one and drew three. The most recent of those was in February 2023, though, and squads change a lot in that time, so I give it little weight.
Verdict
On the evidence available, I lean narrowly towards St Mirren. They have more points from the same goal record, their losing run came mostly against the division's stronger sides, and they arrive off a win. The main risk is their travelling: three straight away defeats, with only one goal scored in them. Given how little either side has scored lately, a draw would not surprise me either.
What would change my view is team news, which isn't confirmed yet. Significant absences on either side would carry more weight than anything in a five-match sample.
Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables).
How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Harvey Watkins's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.


