Skip to main content
Scottish football

Kilmarnock v St Johnstone preview: a leaky defence and a quiet attack

Kilmarnock have conceded more league goals than anyone. St Johnstone have struggled away from home. Saturday's game at Rugby Park turns on which problem shows up.

· · 3 min read

Add as a preferred source on Google
Lucky Tiger News title card: Kilmarnock v St Johnstone preview: a leaky defence and a quiet attack

St Johnstone arrive at Rugby Park with the steadier season behind them, and that gives them a slight edge in my assessment. It is only slight. Their away record is no better than Kilmarnock's home record, and the hosts have been harder to beat at home lately than their league position suggests.

The Scottish Premiership match kicks off at 15:00 on Saturday 31 October. Kilmarnock are 11th on 8 points, level with 10th-placed Motherwell and ahead of bottom side Hibernian, who have 7. St Johnstone are 8th on 12 points, level with Falkirk in 7th.

League recordKilmarnockSt Johnstone
Position11th8th
Won, drawn, lost2, 2, 63, 3, 4
Goals for1011
Goals against2316
Relevant venue recordHome: 1, 1, 3Away: 1, 1, 3
Last five, oldest firstW D L W LL D W D L

Can Kilmarnock keep the score down?

This is the biggest question. Kilmarnock have conceded 23 league goals in 10 matches, the most in the division, and their goal difference of minus 13 is the worst in the table. They let in three at Falkirk last Saturday and three at Rangers earlier this month.

There is a more encouraging thread, though. Their only clean sheet in the last five came in a 1-0 win at Hibernian, and their two most recent home league matches brought a 1-1 draw with Hearts, who are third, and a 3-2 win over Motherwell. That means all three of their home defeats came earlier in the season. The sample is small, so I wouldn't read it as a turnaround, but it does suggest Rugby Park has been less of a problem recently than the overall numbers imply.

Will St Johnstone's attack travel?

St Johnstone's case rests mostly on defence. They have conceded 16, seven fewer than Kilmarnock, and in their last five league matches they haven't scored more than once in any game. They drew 1-1 at home with Falkirk and Dundee United, won 1-0 at Aberdeen, and failed to score in defeats by Celtic and, last weekend, 4-0 at Rangers.

Away from home they have won once, drawn once and lost three times, an identical record to Kilmarnock's at home. Their 11 league goals are only one more than Kilmarnock's 10. If they are going to win here, it is more likely to be through a tight game than an open one.

Does the head-to-head help?

Not much. The sides met at St Johnstone on 2 August, and it finished 4-3 to St Johnstone, which hardly fits either team's profile since. The eight previous league meetings, dating back to January 2021, split four wins for St Johnstone, three for Kilmarnock and one draw, with the most recent of those in April 2024. Squads change over that kind of period, so I'd treat this as background rather than evidence.

Verdict

On the season-long evidence, St Johnstone are the more solid side, and their defensive record is the main reason I give them the edge. The main risk is that their away form has been poor and their attack has been quiet, while Kilmarnock have taken four points from their last two home games. A draw would not contradict anything in the numbers.

What would change my view: confirmed team news, which isn't available yet, and any sign that Kilmarnock's recent home results reflect a genuine defensive improvement rather than a short run. I would reassess once the line-ups are known.

Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables).

How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Harvey Watkins's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.

More Scottish football