Newcastle v Everton preview: home doubts meet a blunted attack
Newcastle have won one of four league games at St James' Park. Everton have no away win and no goals in their last two. Monday's match turns on which weakness shows first.
Add as a preferred source on Google
The evidence leans slightly towards Newcastle United, mainly because Everton have struggled to score. It is only a slight lean. Newcastle's home record is ordinary, their defence has conceded heavily on the road, and several of their players carry availability notes before Monday's Premier League match at St James' Park (20:00 UK time).
Newcastle sit 8th on 11 points from eight matches, with three wins, two draws and three defeats. Everton are 11th on 10 points, with two wins, four draws and two defeats. Three questions should decide the night.
Can Everton find a goal?
This is the biggest issue for the visitors. Everton have scored eight league goals in eight matches. They have scored three in their last five, and drew blanks in three of those games: a 0-0 at Tottenham Hotspur, then a 2-0 home defeat by Chelsea and a 2-0 defeat at Arsenal.
There is useful context for those last two results. Arsenal are second in the table, and Chelsea are fifth. Losing to those sides without scoring is less alarming than the bare form line suggests. Even so, Everton's only goals in that five-match run came in a 1-0 home win over Ipswich Town and a 2-2 draw at Hull City.
Thierno Barry leads Everton with three league goals, and Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall has two. James Tarkowski has one goal and one assist, so the centre-back has been involved in a share of a modest total.
Which Newcastle defence turns up?
Newcastle have conceded 14 league goals, and their record is uneven. They lost 4-1 at Leeds United and 4-1 at Coventry City within their last five matches. Then they kept a clean sheet in a 2-0 win at Crystal Palace last time out.
Home form is the other concern. Newcastle have one win, two draws and one defeat at St James' Park. Their last home match was a 1-0 defeat by Aston Villa, and before that they beat Hull 2-1. Unusually, their away record of two wins and two defeats is the better of the two.
That is why I don't treat home advantage as a strong argument here. Everton's away record cuts both ways too. They haven't won in four away league games, but three of those ended level. A side that is hard to beat, but rarely wins, fits a draw more naturally than a heavy defeat.
How much do Newcastle's absences matter?
Everton have no availability notes. Newcastle have five. Tino Livramento has a knee injury and Ewen Jaouen has a hamstring injury, both with no known return date. William Osula is listed as doubtful with an ankle injury, Miley as doubtful with a muscular injury, and Matias Fernandez-Pardo as doubtful through illness.
Newcastle's goals have been shared out: Harvey Barnes, Anthony Elanga and Joe Willock have two league goals each. Barnes also leads them with three assists, and Dedić has two. None of that trio carries an availability note, so the main attacking routes appear intact. The bigger question is how Newcastle's defensive options are affected, given how many goals they have already conceded. That is a question for confirmed team news, not for this preview.
What about past meetings?
Newcastle won five of the last eight league meetings, Everton won two, and one was drawn. The most recent was a 4-1 Newcastle win at Everton in April 2023. That run is over three seasons old, so I give it very little weight against this season's evidence.
Verdict
I lean towards Newcastle, because Everton's recent attacking output is the clearer weakness of the two. The main risk is Newcastle's own inconsistency: one home win from four and two four-goal defeats away from home. That leaves plenty of room for an Everton side that has drawn three of its four away games.
Two things would change my view. If the doubtful trio all miss out and that disrupts Newcastle's defence, the case for the hosts weakens. If Everton look more threatening than their last five matches suggest, a draw becomes the more natural reading of both teams' records.
Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables); Fantasy Premier League (player availability and match statistics).
How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Harvey Watkins's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.


