Skip to main content
Football

Crystal Palace v Newcastle preview: two defences under pressure at Selhurst Park

Palace have the worst defensive record in the Premier League. Newcastle have conceded four in each of their last two away games. Which defence holds on Sunday?

· · 3 min read

Add as a preferred source on Google
Lucky Tiger News title card: Crystal Palace v Newcastle preview: two defences under pressure at Selhurst Park

Crystal Palace have conceded 17 Premier League goals in seven matches, more than any other side in the division. Newcastle United, who visit Selhurst Park on Sunday 25 October (kick-off 14:00), have let in four in each of their last two away league games. On this evidence, the match turns less on which attack is sharper and more on which defence holds together.

Only a point separates them. Newcastle are 11th on eight points; Palace are 14th on seven.

TeamPosPtsScoredConcededRelevant record (W-D-L)Last five (oldest first)
Crystal Palace147917Home: 1-0-2W L D W L
Newcastle United1181014Away: 1-0-2D L W L L

How much should the Brighton defeat count?

Palace's most recent outing was a 5-0 defeat at Brighton & Hove Albion on 18 October. Context matters here. Brighton are second, with the most goals scored (23) and the fewest conceded (5) in the league, so that was the hardest assignment in the division on current numbers. I wouldn't read too much into the margin alone.

The wider pattern is less forgiving. Palace have conceded in four of their last five league matches, and at home they have won one of three, losing 3-2 to Ipswich Town on 12 September before beating Nottingham Forest 3-1 on 11 October.

The attack is the more encouraging side of the ledger. Palace scored three at Fulham and three against Forest, and the contributions are spread: Tyrick Mitchell leads their league scoring with two goals, Daichi Kamada has three assists and Yeremy has a goal and two assists.

Availability could affect the back line. Dean Henderson is listed as doubtful with a foot injury. Chadi Riad (knee) and Ben Chilwell (unspecified injury) are listed as injured with no return date. Takehiro Tomiyasu is listed with a calf injury and an expected return of 18 October, a date that has already passed, so his involvement is unclear.

Can Newcastle stop conceding on the road?

Newcastle have lost three of their last four league matches. The two away defeats were both 4-1, at Leeds United on 14 September and at Coventry City on 12 October. The Coventry result stands out: Coventry have scored five league goals all season, and four of them came in that match.

The most recent defeat raises a different concern. Newcastle failed to score in a 1-0 home loss to Aston Villa on 17 October, so the issue is not purely defensive.

Anthony Elanga and Joe Willock share the team lead with two league goals each, and Harvey Barnes has three assists. Elanga's status is the key availability question: he is listed with an unspecified injury and is expected back on 25 October, the day of this match. Tino Livramento has an unspecified injury and is expected back on 2 November. Ewen Jaouen (hamstring) and J. Ramsey (thigh) are listed as injured with no return date.

Does the head-to-head tell us much?

Not a great deal. The last eight league meetings date from December 2019 to November 2022. Newcastle won three, Palace two, and three were drawn, including two goalless draws at Newcastle in 2022. None of the eight produced more than three goals. That points to tight, cagey contests, but the squads and circumstances have changed, and neither side's current defensive record looks like the ones that produced those scorelines.

Verdict

I lean narrowly towards Crystal Palace. They have scored five goals in their last two home matches, and Newcastle have conceded eight across their last two away trips. The Brighton result is heavy, but it came against the strongest side Palace have faced on current form.

The main risk is obvious: no team has conceded more than Palace, and a doubt over Henderson adds to that uncertainty. Both defensive records also suggest this could be more open than the old head-to-head implies, which cuts both ways.

What would change my view? If Elanga is fit to start, Newcastle regain one of their two leading scorers and the gap narrows to something close to even.

Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables); Fantasy Premier League (player availability and match statistics).

How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Harvey Watkins's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.

More Football