Celtic v Beşiktaş: visitors stronger, but they leave the door open
Celtic are 35th with no points before Beşiktaş visit on Thursday. The visitors have the better record, but their defence gives Celtic something to aim at.
Add as a preferred source on Google
Celta Vigo have scored three goals in this Europa League. Two of them came at Celtic Park. That's the detail I keep coming back to before Beşiktaş arrive on Thursday, 5 November (20:00 UK, matchday 4), because it says more about Celtic's campaign than the table does.
And the table says plenty. Celtic are 35th of 36: played three, lost three, scored three, conceded nine. Beşiktaş are eighth on seven points, unbeaten after two wins and a draw. The top eight go straight to the round of 16, ninth to 24th go into a two-legged play-off and 25th downwards are out. The visitors are sitting in the bracket everyone wants. Celtic are in the one nobody does, with five matches left including this one.
My view: Beşiktaş have the stronger case, but not by as much as seven points to none suggests. Two questions settle it, and a third tells you where the risk sits.
Can Celtic stop conceding?
Celtic have scored in every match. One goal each time. That keeps you honest; it doesn't keep you in Europe. The problem is what has gone in at the other end: three at home to Ferencváros, four away to Benfica, two at home to Celta Vigo.
The first two come with mitigation. Ferencváros and Benfica are fifth and second, and both have won all three of their matches. Losing to either is no disgrace. Losing 1-2 at home to Celta Vigo, who sit 25th with one win, is much harder to wave away. That was the fixture where Celtic should have been asking the questions, and they still let in two to a side that has found the net once in its other two matches.
Celtic Park hasn't helped either. Two home matches in this competition, two defeats.
How good are Beşiktaş, really?
This is where the strongest objection to my verdict lives. Look at who Beşiktaş have played.
| Team | Result | Opponent's current position |
|---|---|---|
| Beşiktaş | Won 4-1 v Marseille (home) | 34th |
| Beşiktaş | Won 3-2 at Hoffenheim | 23rd |
| Beşiktaş | Drew 2-2 v Crystal Palace (home) | 15th |
| Celtic | Lost 1-3 v Ferencváros (home) | 5th |
| Celtic | Lost 4-1 at Benfica | 2nd |
| Celtic | Lost 1-2 v Celta Vigo (home) | 25th |
Beating Marseille, who have since lost to everyone, is a fine evening rather than a credential. None of Beşiktaş's three opponents are currently in the top 14. Celtic have already faced the sides in second and fifth.
So the seven points flatter Beşiktaş a little, and Celtic's zero is a tougher zero than it looks. But the comparable evidence still points one way. Celtic lost to the weakest side they've faced. Beşiktaş beat the two weakest they've faced and drew with the third. That gap is real, even if the table exaggerates it.
Where Celtic can get at them
Beşiktaş have conceded in every match as well: once against Marseille, twice at Hoffenheim, twice against Palace. A side that lets in two away at the team in 23rd and two at home to the team in 15th is not a locked door. It's their attack, with goals in every game and four in the opener, that has carried them.
That gives Celtic something to work with. They've scored every time out, including against Benfica and Ferencváros, both of whom have tighter defensive records than Beşiktaş. This match is less likely to turn on whether Celtic score than on whether they can keep Beşiktaş to fewer. On three matches of evidence, that's the part of Celtic I can't yet trust.
Verdict
The evidence favours Beşiktaş. They have the better results against the more comparable opposition, they've scored freely, and Celtic's home record in this competition is two played, two lost.
The main risk to that view is the visitors' own defence. Palace drew 2-2 with them, and if Celtic find their usual goal and tighten up behind it, Beşiktaş have shown they can be held. What would make me reassess is Celtic producing the kind of defensive performance they haven't managed once in this group. Until they do, the visitors have the better case, and Celtic have the bigger problem.
Sources: Statorium (fixtures, results and league tables).
How this was written. Drafted with AI assistance from verified sports data in Barrie Moran's style and published after automatic checks for accuracy and compliance, without a line-by-line read by an editor. If you spot a mistake, tell us. Our editorial standards.


